Annex D – GM1 Tactical Mitigation Performance Requirements (TMPR)
CAA ORS9 Decision No. 46
| 1. | Introduction |
| 1.1 | The target audience for Annex D is the UAS operator who wishes to apply Tactical Mitigation Performance Requirement (TMPR), Robustness, Integrity, and Assurance Levels for their operation. Annex D provides the tactical mitigation(s) used to reduce the risk of a Mid-Air Collision (MAC). The TMPR is driven by the residual collision risk of the airspace. Some of these tactical mitigations may also provide a means of compliance with ICAO Annex 2 section 3.2, codified by the FAA in 14 CFR 91.113, “See & Avoid,” SERA 3201, and additional requirements by various states. |
| 1.2 | The Air Risk Model has been developed to provide a holistic method to assess the risk of an air encounter, and to mitigate the risk that an encounter develops in a Mid-Air Collision. The UK SORA Air Risk Model guides the operator, CAA, and/or Air Navigation Service Provider (ANSP) in determining whether an operation may be conducted in a safe manner. This Annex is not intended to be used as a checklist, nor does it provide answers to all the challenges of Detect and Avoid (DAA). The guidance allows an operator to determine and apply a suitable mitigation means to reduce the risk of a Mid-Air Collision (MAC) to an acceptable level. This guidance does not prescriptive requirements but rather objectives to be met at various levels of robustness. |
Tactical Mitigations
| 1.3 | Several tactical mitigation options are presented below: |
| 1.4 | TM1 - Operations under VLOS / BVLOS-with-visual-mitigations – Both VLOS and BVLOS-with-visual-mitigations, following current UK CAA regulations and guidance, are acceptable mitigations for air risk for all ARC levels. The operator is also advised to consider additional means to increase situational awareness with regard to air traffic operating in the vicinity of the operational volume, e.g., via additional tactical mitigations discussed below. In some situations, the CAA and/or ANSP may decide that VLOS does not provide sufficient mitigation for the air risk and may require compliance with additional rules and/or requirements. It is the operator’s responsibility to comply with these rules and requirements. Further information on VLOS UAS operations above 400ft, within controlled airspace, may be found in AMC1 UAS.SPEC.040(1)(b). |
| 1.5 | TM2 - Detect and Avoid (DAA) capability – A UK CAA Policy Concept for the assurance of DAA capabilities is available in CAP3015. Any applicant wishing to use a DAA capability as a tactical air risk mitigation should contact the CAA via uksora@caa.co.uk to obtain further guidance on the review and approval process. |
| 1.6 | TM3 – Carriage of EC out - enhancing the detectability of the UA to other participants. |
| 1.7 | TM4 - Monitoring VHF radio - increasing the situation awareness of a UAS pilot of local air traffic. Note that this mitigation may require some degree of training to understand the monitored radio conversations. |
| 1.8 | TM5 - Monitoring local cooperative traffic - either via low-cost EC receivers or publicly available aircraft tracking applications to increase the situation awareness of an UAS pilot of local air traffic. |
| 1.9 | TM6 - Anti-collision lighting or high visibility colours on the UA - used to enhance the visual detectability of the UAS by the pilot of a conflicting crewed aircraft or any ground personnel. |
| 1.10 | TM7 - Local area real-time weather monitoring - helping to anticipate likelihood of unusual crewed-aircraft traffic patterns. |
| 1.11 | Depending on the specificities of the proposed operating area, one or more of the above mitigations may be required in addition to DAA requirements. The applicant is also encouraged to follow the As Low As Reasonably Practicable (ALARP) principle and apply more tactical mitigations than are required to meet the minimum requirement, if reasonably practicable to do so. |